Thursday, 11 October 2012
Nigeria: Murder of Uniport Students and the Culture of Impunity
Impunity, in international law of human rights, usually denotes the persistent failure to bring perpetrators of human rights violations to justice. This failure on the part of authorities is in itself a denial of the victims' right to justice and redress. In essence, the victims of impunity endure two wrongs: the wrongs inflicted on them by those who choose to trample on their inalienable rights and the wrong done to them by a failure to give them justice by punishing those that trampled on their natural or human rights.
When impunity has become so embedded in any social system that it is regarded as a way of life or 'normal', people talk of the 'culture of impunity'. In this sense the culture of impunity can be regarded as a synonym for what the German-American political scientist Hannah Arendt called the 'banality of evil'. Her explanation of this thesis is that the great evils in history are not executed by fanatics or sociopaths but rather by ordinary people who accepted the premises of their actions and therefore participated in them on the grounds that those heinous actions were normal. This is the so-called notion of 'normalising the unthinkable' or the 'routinisation of evil'. It is within the context of this prevailing culture of impunity or 'culture of normalising the unthinkable' in the land that the murder of four students of the University of Port Harcourt by youths in Omuokiri-Aluu must be situated. It is remarkable that this culture of impunity is especially prevalent in countries that lack a tradition of the rule of law or where corruption is so endemic and pervasive that even the judiciary and its allied justice system are believed to be commoditized. A key manifestation of this culture of impunity is people's knee jerk resort to self-help either in self-defence or to ward off perceived threats.
The stories of what happened at Omuokiri-Aluu are fuzzy and conflicting. The version of the story on which apparently the youths or the vigilante group in the community acted upon was that the four students were either cultists or thieves who stole laptops. The other version is that two of the four boys went to the community to spend a night with a friend but on their way back they met the other two who agreed to accompany them to retrieve money a student and indigene of Aluu owed one of them. This is not abnormal among young people, especially students in a culture of impunity where self-help is the norm. If this version is correct, perhaps in the scuffle that ensued, the debtor felt overpowered and over-numbered and had to what most people under such a circumstance would do: scream 'armed robbers!' to mobilize support. Again this is not a defence of the dastardly act in the community which reportedly claimed that it had been under siege by armed robbers and cultists but to place the reaction of the villagers in its proper context.
It is in fact immaterial which of the competing narratives on what triggered the horrendous murder of the four students is correct. The key issue is the response to their alleged crime. Even if we take the version of the members of the Aluu that the four were thieves (not even armed robbers since they were not apparently armed), there are questions of people taking law into their hands, and even if they must, whether the punishment is proportional to the crime. However when impunity has become a way of life - as it seems to have become in the land- the issue of proportionality is often seen as a luxury by those who feel they must do whatever they must to 'send a message' and ward off threats in the absence of government or anyone else to protect them.
Growing up in Onitsha in the 1970s and 1980s, I remember that armed robbers periodically terrorised the town. After living perpetually in fear of the men of the underworld, residents suddenly came up with the idea of 'Boys Oyee' - a periodic clarion call for solidarity to go after the bad boys. Those who felt they were up to it would gather and chanting 'Boys Oyee', would go after those identified as criminals. Usually those identified would be killed in a most horrendous manner - often by beating them to pulp, stripping them naked, lacing them with tyres and setting them ablaze. The ring leaders of the 'Boys Oyee' - those who had the 'courage' to draw the machete, pour the petrol or set those laced with tyres on fire were often regarded as heroes in the town. I cannot remember complaints about the dastardly manner in which those identified as criminals were killed. The 'joy' was often that the town would be guaranteed 'peace' from miscreants - at least for a while. 'Boys Oyee' is nothing more than a signal that in a Hobbesian State of Nature, characterised by the absence of government which our country seems to have degenerated to, the only thing that seems to work is self-help because the government is not there to help you. Village vigilantes throughout Nigeria came into being because the State has proved incapable or unwilling to secure the life and property of citizens. And various communities across the country use various versions of the 'Boys Oyee' method to either defend themselves or ward off what they consider threats to cherished values.
And by the way this culture of impunity and the barbarity it spurns in its wake manifests in several other realms: when, as writers or word slingers, we prosecute, judge and condemn with venom someone accused of crime or even corruption but who has not been convicted by a competent court of law, we turn ourselves into vigilantes, fighting with the weapon at our disposal. That too is impunity. When a 'big shot' throws his or her weight around and secures some goodies for his or her ward disregarding that the rights of others are being trampled upon while beneficiaries cheer the big shot, that too encourages impunity.
It is understandable and even predictable that students of University of Port Harcourt should seek revenge on members of Omuokiri-Aluu community. The authorities of the University have wisely closed down the institution to allow emotions and tempers to cool. As difficult as it may be - given the sordid manner in which the four were killed - painting the entire Aluu community black will only increase the temptation for vengeance via self-help which paradoxically will encourage the same culture of impunity that led to such acts.
I believe there are several, more important questions we should be asking in order to prevent such from happening again:
One, the students were apparently beaten for a considerable length of time. Was the police aware of the beating, and if so, what effort did they make to remove the boys from the community for their safety?
Two, if it is true that the community has been under siege by armed robbers and cultist, what measures did the police in the village take to allay the fears of the community? How many crimes were committed in the village in the last one year and how many of the perpetrators of such crimes were fished out and brought to justice?
Three, there are some communities in the country that engage in witch-hunting - often based on those identified by a 'babalawo' or Pastor to be a witch. Quite often those identified as witches are buried alive, sometimes with their heads showing or stoned to death. What measures have been taken to bring perpetrators of such crimes to justice and to send a message that such is not acceptable?
Four, how come this culture of impunity is so entrenched in a country where people love to flaunt their religiosity? Is it possible that this entrenchment of the culture of impunity will generate a counter intuitive response to pompous outward display of piety by our people?
I believe that the perpetrators of the dastardly crimes in Aluu must be fished out and speedily brought to justice to serve as deterrence to others. I am a firm believer in capital punishment for those who carry out acts of premeditated murder. So those found guilty should face the music. However I believe that since versions of what happened with the four University students at Omuokiri-Aluu also happen regularly across the length and breadth of the country, we need to go beyond our horrors and moral grandstanding to find out why evil appears to have become truly banal in our land and why people's sensibilities are becoming numbed to acts of horror and barbarity. Simply put we need to find out why people do not trust in government and its institution and increasingly resort to self-help.
Ads by Google
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment